,

Gillette: The Product Was Only the Beginning

Gillette: The Product Was Only the Beginning
Product Strategy · Business Models · Case Study

How a replaceable razor blade helped popularise a business model built around repeat purchases, and what product teams can learn from it today.

Historical case study · Early 1900s · Product and business model strategy

The big idea: What if the first purchase did more than solve a customer’s problem? What if it created a reason for the customer to return, again and again?

Some products make money when a customer buys them. Others create an ongoing relationship that continues long after the first transaction. The difference can transform a business.

In the early 1900s, Gillette helped establish a powerful example of this second approach. It introduced a reusable safety razor designed to hold thin, replaceable blades. Customers bought the razor once, but the blades became a repeat purchase as the original ones dulled.

The product was not simply a razor. It was a system: a durable device, a replaceable component, a reason to replenish that component, and a commercial relationship that could continue over time.

Today, this pattern is widely known as the razor-and-blades business model. Its influence reaches far beyond grooming, from printers and ink cartridges to coffee machines and capsules, and from hardware devices to ongoing software services.

The product lesson: Do not design only for the moment a customer buys. Design the experience, economics and ongoing value that give customers a good reason to come back.

1. The problem before the product

To understand Gillette’s opportunity, it helps to understand the shaving experience before replaceable safety razor blades became widely available.

Traditional straight razors could provide a close shave, but they required care and skill. Their edges dulled and needed maintenance, including sharpening or stropping. Shaving at home could be inconvenient, while visiting a barber meant spending time and money.

King Camp Gillette, a travelling salesman, saw an opportunity to make shaving more convenient. His idea was to use a thin, sharp piece of steel that could be fitted into a reusable holder and replaced when it became dull.

The important innovation was not just a new handle or a sharper blade. It was the separation of the long-lasting part of the product from the part that wore out.

Instead of maintaining an entire cutting tool, customers could keep the holder and replace the blade. The design offered a more convenient way to maintain a sharp edge without repeatedly sharpening a traditional razor.

Gillette developed the idea during the 1890s and worked with engineer William Emery Nickerson to solve the manufacturing challenges. The American Safety Razor Company was formed in 1901, and commercial production began in 1903. The company later became known as the Gillette Safety Razor Company.

This was a product innovation, but it also created the foundations of a recurring-revenue opportunity.

2. The business model hiding inside the design

A conventional durable product often has a simple commercial pattern: acquire a customer, sell the product, and wait for that customer to need another one. The next sale might be years away.

Gillette’s design created a different pattern. The handle could last through many shaving sessions, but the blade had a limited useful life. The customer did not need to replace the entire product to continue getting value from it.

That small design decision changed the relationship between the product and its customer.

The commercial system

  1. Initial purchase: The customer buys a reusable razor.
  2. Product use: The customer shaves with the razor and blade.
  3. Natural wear: The blade gradually becomes dull.
  4. Replacement need: The customer needs another blade to maintain the experience.
  5. Repeat purchase: The customer buys compatible replacement blades.
  6. Ongoing relationship: The company can continue serving the customer through future replacements and product improvements.

The customer receives continued value from the original device. The business receives opportunities to earn revenue beyond the initial sale. When the product works well and replacements remain convenient, both sides have a reason to continue the relationship.

One important historical distinction

It is tempting to assume that Gillette immediately sold cheap razors and made its money from expensive blades. That familiar version of the model should not be projected backwards onto the company’s entire early history.

Historical accounts indicate that Gillette initially sold its razor sets at a substantial price. The company also benefited from advertising, manufacturing improvements, distribution and patent protection. The razor-and-blades model became a broader commercial concept over time; Gillette’s early success was not simply the result of giving away the handle and charging for blades.

The enduring insight is the relationship between the durable product and the consumable, not a claim that every part of the modern pricing strategy was present from the beginning.

3. The numbers reveal the potential

The early sales figures demonstrate how quickly the product gained traction. Harvard Business School’s profile of King C. Gillette records that the company sold just 51 razors and 168 blades in 1903. By the end of the following year, sales had increased dramatically.

51 Razors sold in 1903, the company’s first year of commercial sales.
168 Blades sold during that same year.
90,000 Approximately the number of razors sold by the end of 1904.
12.4 million Blades sold by the end of 1904, according to Harvard Business School’s account.

These figures should not be read as proof that the replacement model alone caused the company’s growth. Manufacturing capacity, distribution, promotion, market conditions and other commercial decisions mattered. But the difference between the number of durable devices sold and the much larger volume of blades illustrates the commercial potential of repeat-use consumables.

One customer could purchase a razor and then buy blades many times. The business was no longer dependent on persuading that customer to replace the entire device every time a component wore out.

4. Why this matters to product management

The most useful lesson for a product manager is not simply to introduce a subscription, sell accessories or add recurring charges. It is to understand how product design, customer value and commercial sustainability fit together.

Gillette’s approach prompts a different set of product questions:

  • Which part of the product provides lasting value?
  • Which part naturally wears out, gets used up or needs ongoing support?
  • Can the customer continue receiving value without replacing the whole product?
  • Can the business serve the customer again in a way that is genuinely useful?
  • Will customers return because the product continues to work well, rather than because the company has made leaving difficult?

These questions matter whether the product is a physical device, a healthcare platform, an AI tool or a business software service.

The objective is not to manufacture dependency. It is to create a product that remains useful over time, with a sustainable way to fund that value.

5. How I would develop a product using this principle

Imagine a company wants to launch a smart home air-quality monitor. It could sell a device and earn revenue once. Or it could build a broader product experience around the device, including replacement filters, monitoring, alerts and optional services.

The opportunity is promising, but the recurring-revenue model should not be assumed to be right just because it works in another category. I would approach the product in stages.

01

Start with the customer problem, not the revenue mechanism

First, establish what customers are struggling with and how they currently solve it. For an air-quality monitor, customers might want to understand indoor air quality, know when ventilation is needed, or replace filters before performance declines.

I would interview prospective customers, observe existing behaviours where possible, review competitor products and investigate the circumstances in which customers would actually use the solution.

I would also identify which customer segments have the strongest need. A household with allergy concerns, a childcare centre and a commercial building operator may have very different expectations and willingness to pay.

Output: A clearly defined target segment, evidence of the problem, and a problem statement that can guide product decisions.

02

Separate the durable product from the ongoing value

Next, map the components of the product and understand which parts create value once and which may create value repeatedly.

For the monitor, the hardware is the durable component. Filters may be consumables. Software alerts and historical reports could form part of an ongoing digital service.

I would distinguish between three things:

  • Core product: What the customer needs to achieve the primary outcome.
  • Replacement or maintenance: What is genuinely needed to keep the product performing well.
  • Additional services: What creates incremental value for customers who want more.

This distinction prevents a common mistake: putting essential functionality behind a recurring fee simply to create revenue, even when the fee does not correspond to ongoing value.

Output: A product architecture and value map that shows what is included initially, what needs replacement, and what optional services might be worth developing.

03

Validate the product and the business model separately

A customer may want the product but dislike the pricing model. Equally, a business model may look attractive in a spreadsheet but fail to deliver enough value to persuade customers to buy.

I would test both questions before making a major investment. Early prototypes could help validate the device’s usefulness. Concept tests, landing pages, pricing interviews or paid pilots could provide evidence of demand and willingness to pay.

I would compare different commercial options:

  • A one-time hardware purchase with replacement filters sold separately.
  • A device-and-filter bundle.
  • An optional subscription for monitoring and advanced reports.
  • A business package with multiple devices and centralised reporting.

The aim is to learn which model customers understand, value and actually choose, rather than selecting the model with the most attractive theoretical revenue.

Output: Evidence of product demand, pricing sensitivity and the commercial model most worth testing further.

04

Design the repeat-use experience before launch

Repeat revenue depends on what happens after the first purchase. The product team needs to design that journey deliberately.

For the air-quality monitor, that could include easy device setup, clear readings, useful alerts, visible filter compatibility, straightforward reordering and timely reminders based on actual usage or filter condition.

I would work with engineering, design, operations and commercial teams to identify the dependencies behind this experience. For example, replacement reminders are only helpful if the product has a reliable way to estimate filter life and the company can fulfil orders consistently.

I would avoid reminders that create unnecessary urgency or encourage customers to replace components before they need to. Convenience should be earned through relevance and reliability.

Output: An end-to-end experience covering setup, regular use, maintenance, replenishment, support and renewal where applicable.

05

Build a business case around the full customer lifecycle

A product with repeat purchases can look attractive because each customer may generate revenue more than once. However, repeat revenue does not automatically mean repeat profit.

I would model the initial sale and the ongoing relationship together. That includes manufacturing costs, acquisition costs, fulfilment, support, returns, replacement frequency, subscription costs and customer retention.

For example, an inexpensive device may attract customers but lose money if customer acquisition and support costs are too high. Conversely, a profitable device may become a stronger business when customers voluntarily return for replacements or services.

The model should use realistic assumptions and test what happens when customers replace filters less often than expected, cancel subscriptions early or cost more to support.

Output: A business case with transparent assumptions, unit economics, break-even scenarios and risks.

06

Launch narrowly, learn quickly and expand with evidence

Rather than launching every possible feature and commercial option at once, I would begin with a focused segment and a product that solves its primary problem well.

A pilot could test whether customers successfully set up the device, continue using it, understand its readings and return for necessary replacements. It could also reveal operational issues such as fulfilment delays, compatibility confusion or excessive support requests.

I would review the evidence with the team at regular intervals and decide whether to improve the core product, adjust pricing, refine the replenishment experience or expand into another segment.

Output: A prioritised product roadmap grounded in observed behaviour, customer feedback and commercial performance.

6. What would the product roadmap look like?

A useful roadmap would not start with a long list of features. It would show how the product earns the right to grow by reducing uncertainty and delivering value in stages.

Stage Product focus Key question Evidence to progress
Discovery Customer research, competitor analysis, problem validation. Is this a meaningful problem for a reachable customer segment? Consistent customer evidence and a defined target segment.
Prototype Test the core product and its most important user interactions. Can customers use the product and get the promised value? Successful task completion, useful feedback and evidence of demand.
MVP Core device, essential software, setup and basic support. Can we deliver the core outcome reliably? Activation, product usage, reliability and early retention signals.
Repeat-use pilot Replacement reminders, ordering and optional ongoing services. Will customers return because the ongoing offer is useful? Observed repeat purchases, customer satisfaction and viable margins.
Scale Distribution, operational efficiency, additional segments and product improvements. Can the business grow without weakening customer value or economics? Consistent retention, positive unit economics and reliable operations.

The sequence matters. Building subscriptions and replenishment features before validating the core product can create complexity without solving the underlying problem. A recurring business model should reinforce a successful product, not compensate for an unsuccessful one.

7. How should a product manager measure success?

If the product is designed to create a long-term customer relationship, measuring only initial sales is insufficient. A product team needs to understand whether customers activate, receive value, return when appropriate and remain commercially sustainable.

Product and customer metrics

  • Activation rate: The percentage of customers who complete setup and reach the product’s first meaningful outcome.
  • Time to value: How long it takes a customer to experience the core benefit.
  • Repeat purchase rate: The percentage of eligible customers who purchase a replacement or consumable again within a defined period.
  • Retention: The percentage of customers who continue using the product over time.
  • Customer satisfaction: Whether customers find the product and replenishment experience useful, reliable and fair.
  • Return and complaint rates: Whether customers experience defects, compatibility problems or unexpected costs.

Commercial metrics

  • Average revenue per customer: Revenue generated over a defined period, including initial and repeat purchases.
  • Gross margin: Revenue remaining after the direct costs of supplying the product or service.
  • Customer acquisition cost: The cost of acquiring a customer.
  • Customer lifetime value: The expected contribution from a customer over the relationship, based on explicit assumptions.
  • Payback period: How long it takes to recover the cost of acquiring a customer.
  • Subscription cancellation rate: The percentage of subscribers who cancel during a defined period, where subscriptions are offered.

These metrics should be interpreted together. A high repeat-purchase rate is not necessarily good if customers are dissatisfied, replacements are being bought prematurely, or fulfilment costs make each transaction unprofitable.

Likewise, low replacement frequency is not automatically a problem. Customers may simply be using the product as intended. The relevant question is whether they continue to receive the promised value and whether the business model remains viable.

8. The trade-offs a product team must consider

The razor-and-blades model can be powerful, but it creates product and commercial risks. A product manager should identify these early instead of treating recurring revenue as an unquestioned goal.

Compatibility versus customer freedom

Replacement components need to work reliably with the original device. Compatibility can support product quality, but unnecessarily restricting customers to one supplier can create frustration and undermine trust. The team should make the reasons for compatibility requirements clear.

Recurring revenue versus customer value

A recurring payment is only defensible when the customer receives continuing value. If the product can work perfectly well without an expensive subscription, the business should be careful about putting basic functionality behind a paywall.

Convenience versus waste

Consumables create repeat demand, but they also create material use and disposal. Product teams should consider durability, repairability, recycling, packaging and the environmental impact of replacement cycles.

Growth versus trust

Aggressive reminders, confusing subscription terms and artificially short replacement cycles might increase short-term revenue but damage long-term loyalty. Transparent pricing, easy cancellation and honest recommendations are product decisions as much as commercial decisions.

Customer lock-in versus genuine loyalty

A customer who stays because switching is difficult is different from one who stays because the product consistently performs well. A sustainable product should aim for the second kind of relationship.

9. Where we see this model today

The same broad principle appears in many modern products, although the economics and customer expectations vary considerably by category.

Printers and ink cartridges

The printer is the durable device; ink and toner are consumables. Product teams must balance purchase price, print quality, cartridge availability and the ongoing cost of ownership.

Coffee machines and capsules

The machine enables repeated preparation, while capsules or other consumables create repeat purchasing opportunities. Convenience, taste, availability and waste are important parts of the experience.

Connected hardware and software services

A device may provide its core function at purchase, while optional software, cloud storage, monitoring or advanced analytics offer ongoing value. The team must establish which capabilities genuinely require continuing service and which should remain available without an additional fee.

Business software platforms

In SaaS, the recurring component is not necessarily a consumable. It may be access to a service that continues to deliver value through workflow automation, reporting, collaboration, security, maintenance and product improvements. The commercial model differs, but the principle of earning an ongoing customer relationship remains relevant.

10. What I would take from Gillette as a product manager

Gillette’s story is a useful reminder that product strategy and business model design are closely connected. A seemingly small design choice, such as making one component replaceable, can change how customers use a product and how a company earns revenue.

But the lesson is not that every product needs a consumable, subscription or recurring charge. Some products are better sold as one-time purchases. Others create ongoing value through services, maintenance, support or continuous software improvements.

The right model depends on the customer’s needs, the nature of the product, the cost of delivering ongoing value and the economics of serving customers over time.

A strong product does more than win the first sale. It gives customers a reason to keep choosing it, while giving the business a sustainable way to keep delivering value.

That is the principle I would carry into product development: understand the full lifecycle, design for continued usefulness, test the commercial assumptions, measure the relationship beyond the initial transaction, and never confuse repeat revenue with customer success.

Sources and further reading

Historical context and early sales figures:

  1. Harvard Business School — King C. Gillette
    An overview of Gillette’s business history and early sales.
  2. Smithsonian National Museum of American History — Gillette Razor Blade
    Historical context on the replaceable-blade invention and company.
  3. Razor-and-Blades Pricing Revisited
    A discussion of the model and the historical nuance of Gillette’s pricing strategy.
  4. Science Museum Group — Gillette Safety Razor
    Additional historical information about the product and its development.

This article distinguishes between the historical record and the modern product-management framework. The development process, hypothetical air-quality product and recommended metrics are illustrative applications, not claims about Gillette’s original internal product process.

Product Strategy Case Study · Gillette · The razor-and-blades model

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *